One problem, three answers. A delivery rider is told by an algorithm when to ride, what he is paid, and when he is punished — and is then told he is not a worker. Three jurisdictions have answered that contradiction in law. This dossier compares them, because the comparison is the practical syllabus for any future Chinese labour law.
Spain: presume employment (2021)
Spain’s “Riders’ Law” (Royal Decree-Law 9/2021) wrote a presumption of employment into law for platform delivery riders: the platform that organises the work through an algorithm is the employer, unless it proves otherwise. The same law gave works councils the right to be informed of the parameters of the algorithms that govern working conditions — the first statutory right of its kind.
The European Union: presumption plus algorithmic management (2024)
Directive (EU) 2024/2831 on improving working conditions in platform work, in force since 1 December 2024 with transposition due by December 2026, generalises the Spanish answer: a rebuttable legal presumption of employment where the platform controls the work, and binding rules on algorithmic management — transparency of automated decisions, human oversight, and a bar on processing riders’ private data. Some twenty-eight million platform workers are in its scope.
China: protection without status (2021)
China’s answer came on 26 July 2021, in the eight-department Guiding Opinions on safeguarding the rights of workers in new forms of employment. It created an intermediate category — workers who “do not fully meet the conditions for a labour relationship” — owed some protections but not the status of employee, and a companion food-delivery guideline ruled that “the strictest algorithm shall not be used as the assessment requirement”. The December 2021 Trade Union Law amendment opened union membership in words to the roughly 84 million workers in new forms of employment. Chinese lawyers said at the time what this desk records as the finding: a right that a rider must first prove employee status to use is no right at all. Spain and the EU start from the presumption that the worker is a worker. China starts from the presumption that he is not, and negotiates exceptions. That ordering — presumption first, or status first — is the whole argument, and it is the argument this desk exists to document.
Research dossier of the International Association of Chinese Workers — International Labour Law & Practice desk. Opened 30 October 2026.